
Day-After
Turkey Sandwich
with Balsamic Onions
Leftover turkey, melted cheddar and jammy Red Apple balsamic onions on sourdough, grilled golden in Wild Mushroom and Sage Olive Oil.
For the Friday after Thanksgiving, when the fridge is full and nobody wants to cook a whole meal. This one turns the leftover turkey into something worth looking forward to.
Slow-cooked onions get a splash of our Red Apple Dark Balsamic and turn sweet and jammy. Brushing the bread with Wild Mushroom and Sage Olive Oil instead of butter gives it a golden, savory crust that tastes like the holiday all over again.
Why Cook the Onions Low and Slow?
Onions need time to turn sweet. Keep the heat at medium-low and give them 25 to 30 minutes, stirring now and then. On high heat they burn before they soften. The balsamic goes in at the very end, so it glazes the onions instead of cooking off.

The Sweet Side
Red Apple Dark Balsamic
Sweet and mellow, like biting into a crisp red apple. Three tablespoons turn plain onions jammy. It's also great in a fall salad vinaigrette or as a glaze for pork.
Shop This Product
The Golden Crust
Wild Mushroom and Sage Olive Oil
Earthy mushroom and warm sage in every pour. It cooks the onions and crisps the bread, so the sandwich tastes like Thanksgiving dinner. Try it on roasted potatoes or brushed on turkey too.
Shop This ProductFrom Michelle's Kitchen
Day-After Turkey Sandwich
One skillet for the onions, one for the sandwiches.
Ingredients
- 2 tbsp Wild Mushroom and Sage Olive Oil, for the onions
- 2 large yellow onions, thinly sliced
- Pinch of salt
- 3 tbsp Red Apple Dark Balsamic
- 8 slices sourdough
- 2 tbsp Wild Mushroom and Sage Olive Oil, for brushing
- 12 oz leftover turkey, sliced
- 4 oz sharp cheddar or brie, sliced
- 1 apple, thinly sliced
- A handful of arugula
- Leftover cranberry sauce or Dijon mustard (optional)
Instructions
- Heat 2 tbsp of the oil in a skillet over medium-low. Add the onions and salt and cook 25 to 30 minutes, stirring now and then, until soft and golden. Add the balsamic and cook 2 to 3 minutes until jammy.
- Brush one side of each bread slice with oil. Flip 4 slices oil side down and layer the cheese, turkey, onions, apple and arugula. Spread cranberry sauce or Dijon on the other 4 slices and close, oil side out.
- Cook in a skillet over medium for 3 to 4 minutes per side, pressing gently, until the bread is golden and the cheese melts.
Make It Your Own
No turkey left? Rotisserie chicken works just as well. Swap the cheddar for brie for a creamier melt. Prefer it cold? Skip the grilling and drizzle a little of the oil and balsamic over the arugula instead.
Questions We Get About This One
Can I make the balsamic onions ahead?
Yes. They keep in the fridge for up to a week. Warm them in a skillet or use them straight from the fridge.
What can I use instead of turkey?
Rotisserie chicken works just as well, and leftover ham is good too.
Which cheese works best?
Sharp cheddar gives it a little tang. Brie melts creamier and goes great with the apple.
Can I eat it cold?
Sure. Skip the grilling and drizzle a little of the oil and balsamic over the arugula instead.
Make a double batch of the onions and keep them in a jar. A spoonful on a burger, a grilled cheese or a cheese board makes it taste like you planned ahead.
Come taste before you buy.
Stop by our Glen Ellyn store to try both bottles before you make Michelle’s sandwich at home.
449 N. Main Street, Glen Ellyn, IL 60137 · (630) 534-6457
Mon–Fri 10am–5:30pm · Sat 10am–5pm
Browse More Recipes